Source URL: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/cu2E8wgmbdZbqeWqb/meemi-s-shortform
Source: Hacker News
Title: OpenAI funded FrontierMath Benchmarks and had access to the set
Feedly Summary: Comments
AI Summary and Description: Yes
Summary: The text discusses concerns regarding non-transparency in the funding and communication between OpenAI and Epoch AI related to the FrontierMath project. It highlights potential privacy and security implications for contractors involved in creating benchmark questions, emphasizing the importance of clear disclosure and communication about funding and data usage, crucial for professionals in AI security and compliance.
Detailed Description: The text raises awareness about several critical issues involving transparency, funding, and security within the context of the FrontierMath project supported by OpenAI. Here are the major points discussed:
– **Funding Transparency**:
– OpenAI’s funding of FrontierMath was not publicly communicated until December 20th, raising issues regarding transparency.
– Earlier versions of related documents did not mention OpenAI’s support, indicating a lack of openness during the project’s development.
– **Secrecy and Confidentiality**:
– Contractors creating questions for the FrontierMath benchmark were instructed to maintain confidentiality, using secure communication methods and signing NDAs to prevent leakage of materials.
– The text implies that there may have been a disconnect between the contractors and the overarching funding relationship with OpenAI.
– **Potential Misuse of Data**:
– There are implications that OpenAI may have access to the exercises and answers generated by contractors, despite no clear agreement prohibiting this access for training purposes.
– This raises concerns regarding the possibility of using confidential data for broader capabilities without contractor awareness.
– **Call for Disclosure**:
– The author advocates for greater disclosure from Epoch AI regarding OpenAI’s funding and the implications for contractors, especially when individuals decide whether to participate in such projects.
– There is a concern that inadequate information can lead to a lack of informed consent among contractors involved.
– **Community Reactions**:
– The text references discussions on platforms like HackerNews and articles from Ars Technica highlighting the ongoing debates surrounding FrontierMath’s questions remaining unpublished to hinder AI companies from training against them.
In conclusion, the text underscores the critical need for enhanced transparency and regulatory compliance in projects involving AI funding and contractor participation. Security and compliance professionals should take note of the implications for data privacy and ethical considerations in AI development and collaboration.